Rostow 1971 suggested that following initial investment, countries would then set off on an evolutionary process in which they would progress up 5 stages of a development ladder. Modernization theory stresses the functional necessity of efficient bureaucracy for welfare state development because, without it, effective taxation and administration of complex distributional programs is simply impossible. Sep 19, 2017 the most wellknown version of modernization theory is walt rostows 5 stages of economic growth. A critique of modernization and dependency theories in.
Still, since our purpose is not the piecemeal criticism of one or another version of modernization theory but the evaluation of modernization theory itself as. The principal criticism of dependency theories has been that the school does not provide any substantive empirical evidences to support its arguments. Pdf development and modernization theory handout perin. The endogenous explanation is a modernization theory. Modernization theory stresses not only the process of change but also the responses to that change. Some might say that modernization theory collapsed but it can be argued that the very act of recognizing its flaws made the theory even stronger. Full text views reflects the number of pdf downloads. Modernization theory vs dependency theory while many theorists have numerous explanations towards underdevelopment, experts like david brooks and peter hallward have described the natural disaster in haiti to be brutally destructive primarily due to its poverty. But that, in itself, suggests an additional problem, which is that.
Dec 01, 2016 1 modernization theory of development 1. This article provides information about the critique of modernisation theories based on the dependency theory of development. In this sense, the dependency theory can be viewed as a reaction to modernization theory. Pdf this paper provides a bold critique of the hegemonic dualism in the light of insights that tariq banuri has offered. However, the way modernization theory suggests for development and.
The basic assumption of this theory, in any of its versions, is that there is one gen. A critique of modernization and dependency theories in africa. First of all, it should be said that dependency theory was developed in response to modernization theory out of sheer criticism of the latter theory by the supporters of dependency theory. Modernization theory is subject to criticism originating among socialist and freemarket ideologies, worldsystems theorists. An outline and critique of competing theories by dieter nohlen, heidelberg. Aug 31, 2019 the modernization theory is polarized in its reception. Pye 2008, oxford handbook of contextual political analysis, it has only lost its initial enthusiasm p. Definition of modernization theory in the dictionary. Development rostows of development and ist relevance in. Review journal a paper for theory of political economic development this journal was written by j. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
Modernization theory oxford research encyclopedia of. Modernization and its discontents 1 the crisis in modernization theory 5 towards a sociology of knowledge 11 2. Modernization theory describes the transformative processes of societies from underdevelopment to modern societies. Sep 27, 2015 modernisation theory historical context 1940s and 50s by the end of ww2 it had become clear that despite exposure to capitalism many of the countries of the south had failed to develop. An annotated foreign affairs syllabus on modernization theory. Modernization theory vs dependency theory 1227 words 5 pages.
Recently, however,several articles present a more penetrating and systematic criticism. The modernization theory is polarized in its reception. Information and translations of modernization theory in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. Modernization theory is a grand theory encompassing many different disciplines as it seeks to explain how society progresses, what variables affect that progress, and how societies can react to that progress. Matunhu department of development studies, midlands state university, zimbabwe and published in african journal of history and culture vol. It is not simply an increase in the gross domestic product gdp. Numerous criticisms have been leveled at rostows scheme. Farhan ahmad faiz 2 historical background to modernization theory 1 post world war twos deepening poverty in some countries 2 ideological competition from communism 3 increasing unrest in some countries 4 the above posed a threat to capitalism, and especially the usa 5 this led to the development of.
Dec 14, 2015 a brief discussion of rostows modernization model and some of the major criticisms of the model. Modernization theory, strengths and weaknesses by watila development is an elusive concept to define. Bureaucracy, once erected, may also come to play an active role in decisionmaking and thus determine policy evolution. Introduction with the strong postwar economic recovery of the developed nations and the birth of many new nations formerly under colonial rule there was in the 1950s and 1960s considerable. Modernization theory is used to explain the process of modernization within societies. Modernization, modernization theory and its criticism. John gow semester 012005 oliver basu mallick student id 3042542 mail oliver. Modernisation theory had two major aims it attempted to explain why poorer. Tipps skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. A decade of feminist criticism volume 34 issue 2 jane s. It involves catching up to progress that has occurred in areas such as efficiency, productivity, quality of life and risk reduction. Modernisation theory development and underdevelopment. Modernization, dependency, rural underdevelopment, african. Critics of dependency theory social science theories.
On rostows stages thesis and explanation of takeoff growth matthew smith university of sydney 1. They fail to understand that value systems and institutions tend to be culturespecific. Good tool for revision as it compacts important information into a non daunting, accessible pdf. Modernization theory itself, however, takes no stance on whether modernization is a good or bad thing. Critique of modernisation theories based on the dependency. Instead, it represents a broad framework within which to look at the pros and cons of globalization and the worldwide migration from agrarian societies to. Modernization theory is a model of economic and social development that explains global inequality in terms of differing levels of technological development among societies.
Modernization theory studies the process of social evolution and the development of societies. Modernization is seen at the level of economics, as well as the ways in which these traditional approaches are subjected to clinical trials and then standardized, commodified, and mass distributedsuch as the curative use of artemesinin qing hao for malaria, and the controversial patent of the neem tree azadirachta indica for its medicinal properties figure 12. It is a us and europeancentric normative model of development. On rostows stages thesis and explanation of takeoff.
Comparison of dependency theory with modernization theory. Naturally, this fact determined the principal difference between these theories, but, nevertheless, there are still certain similarities between. The terms have been used by so many scholars in so many ways that my general line of criticism certainly does not apply to all. In this context, in the late 1940s, modernisation theory was developed. Farhan ahmad faiz 2 historical background to modernization theory 1 post world war twos deepening poverty in some countries 2 ideological competition from communism 3 increasing unrest in some countries 4 the above posed a threat to capitalism, and especially the usa 5 this led to the. Modernization theory and the comparative study of societies. In analysing the assets of the modernisation theories, it should be understood that this school of thought emerged in the early years of the 1950s, and began to disappear in the 1970s when belief in it started to wane. Modernisation is about africa following the developmental footsteps. A brief discussion of rostows modernization model and some of the major criticisms of the model. Both modernisation and dependency theory make the mistake of treating ldcs least developed countries as homogeneous i. There are few examples that are provided but many exceptions are there which do not fit in with their core periphery theory, like the newly emerged industrial countries of south east asia. There is, presumably, a need to make traditional societies beliefs and attitudes more rational.
The writer used development theories inline with modernization and dependency theories to find out its effect to. Society for comparative studies in society and history. Modernization theory modernisation theory has been defined as a theory reyes, 2001a that uses a systematic process to move underdeveloped countries to a more sophisticated level of development. Dec 08, 20 weaknesses and strenths of modernization theory 1. Modernisation and dependency repub, erasmus university. The discourse pins hope on the african renaissance theory of development. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise cambridge core to connect with your account. Rostow believes that every society must pass through these stages on the. Modernization consists of a gradual differentiation and specialization of social structures. According to modernization theory, development will arrive in traditional societies after the modernization of their beliefs and attitudes.
The most wellknown version of modernization theory is walt rostows 5 stages of economic growth. The basic assumption of this theory, in any of its versions, is that there is one general end page 157 process of which democratization is but the final stage. In the words of one of the major proponents, historically, modernization is the process of change towards those types of social, economic, and. Modernization theorists only see western economies as completely modern and deem other economies to be unevolved or primitive.
It is automatically assumed by thinkers like rostow that this is the correct way for an underdeveloped society to develop. Modernization theory is subject to criticism originating among socialist and freemarket ideologies, worldsystems theorists, globalization theorists and dependency theorists among others. Modernization theory an overview sciencedirect topics. The most popular criticism would revolve around the idea of ethnocentrism, or the assumption that how economic and social progress has worked in certain countries would work equally as well elsewhere.
In such a way, this theory views modernization of socioeconomic and political life of developing countries on the basis of the example of western countries as the only possible solution of the problem of backwardness of poor countries since western way of development is, according to modernization theory, is the only correct way to prosperity. Critics argue that the theory and model do not take into account the differences between capitalistic vs. Apr 12, 2018 modernization theory is subject to criticism originating among socialist and freemarket ideologies, worldsystems theorists, globalization theorists and dependency theorists among others. Although it is true, to a large extent, that modernization approach is still valid for the economic, social and political development of the countries, the approach has appeared questionable to many scholars of the field. Modernization theory refers to a variety of nonmarxist perspectives which have been put forward to explain the development or underdevelopment of countries. Modernisation theory is typically a western phenomenon. Sep 29, 2019 still others critique modernization theory for failing to account for the unsustainable nature of the project, in an environmental sense, and point out that premodern, traditional, and indigenous cultures typically had much more environmentally conscious and symbiotic relationships between people and the planet. There are two levels of analysis in classical modernization theory. However, the information on rostows model for development is unclear, and to put it nicely questionable. Modernization theory the belief that industrialization and economic development lead directly to positive social and political change has been a subject of intense scholarly and policy interest for more than half a century. Modernization theory focuses specifically on a type of modernization thought to. Modernisation theory is the fundamental proposition that people in traditional societies should adopt the characteristics of modern societies in order to modernize their social, political and economic institutions.
Jan 03, 2014 a critique of modernization and dependency theories in africa. Modernization theory and the comparative study of national societies. Still others critique modernization theory for failing to account for the unsustainable nature of the project, in an environmental sense, and point out that premodern, traditional, and indigenous cultures typically had much more environmentally conscious and symbiotic relationships between people and the planet. Modernization, modernization theory a term and approach that came into widespread use in the early 1960s, as a consequence of the efforts by a group of development specialists in the united states to develop an alternative to the marxist account of social development. Modernization theory is a description and explanation of the processes of transformation from traditional or underdeveloped societies to modern societies. The concept of modernization is rooted in the numerous sets of dichotomies between tradition and modernity well known to social. Modernization theory, on the other hand, was popular in the 1950s, but was under heavy attack at the end of the 60s. Difference between modernization theory and dependency theory. The concept of modernization incorporates the full spectrum of the transition and drastic transformation that a traditional society has to undergo in order to become modern hussain et al.
577 744 1159 1169 1458 439 132 716 1134 1377 328 140 961 1455 1457 59 647 939 1344 724 769 1081 1370 963 746 467 1260 1018 1306 402 1017 746 1396 951 584 1050 1200 1069 785